Categories
Links Siri

Apple’s China Siri Deal Raises the Privacy Question It Can’t Avoid

From Ben Lovejoy at 9to5Mac:

Apple has revealed that the new Siri AI features in China will use Alibaba’s Qwen models instead of Google’s Gemini models. The Chinese government requires Apple to work with a local AI company, and Apple has now published a Chinese-language guide explaining how users can connect Siri and Writing Tools to Qwen.

That arrangement is a sharp contrast with Apple’s stated privacy architecture everywhere else. Siri requests can run on-device, through Apple’s Private Cloud Compute servers, or through Google infrastructure dedicated to Apple. Apple says those systems are designed so that neither Apple nor Google can access or retain users’ interactions.

The China-specific setup appears to have a meaningful difference: Mac users need their own Qwen account and must sign into it. That requirement suggests the same privacy guarantees may not apply, although Apple has not publicly explained the full data-handling model yet.

This is the uncomfortable tradeoff at the center of Apple’s AI strategy. Apple can preserve its preferred privacy model when it controls the infrastructure and the rules. In China, local regulatory requirements determine which model can be used—and may also determine how much privacy the system can promise.

The feature may still be useful: Qwen can provide more detailed Siri responses, analyze photos and documents, and help Writing Tools create text or images. But the important question is not only whether Siri works in China. It is whether Apple can offer the same privacy boundary there that it treats as a defining part of Siri AI everywhere else.

Read the full report at 9to5Mac.

Categories
Links Siri WWDC

Joanna Stern: It’s Weird To Sit With the Silence of Siri

On The Talk Show Live at WWDC26, John Gruber and Joanna Stern had the following exchange:

Gruber:

We talked about the fact that the overall keynote was very short compared to the previous one.

It’s hard to imagine them ever having a WWDC keynote that would be less time, but… … …I’m pausing for effect, because that included a lot of really long pauses for the demo.”

[Laughter]

“Because, as you said Joanna, they shot them as though they were on tape – but they were, like, live to tape.”

Joanna:

“And there was no doubt when you were watching – you were just like, ‘Okay, that’s a long pause because that is the real-time demo.’

Which was absolutely a reaction to watch happened to two years ago, and they wanted none of that.

And even as Nilay would say – it is not a joke how many times they said, ‘We want you to go download the software. We want you to go try it. We want you to know that what we showed was real and now we want you to experience it.’

Not what happened two years ago.

Gruber:

Were you at the Tech Talk at noon that Nilay was talking about? (Joanna: Yes, I was sitting next to him) Because they did live demos there too.

Joanna:

[…] Yeah. But you could see – they were nervous. Even though you knew that this was a pretty canned live demo and that they knew what they were going to ask.

[…]

They weren’t taking requests from us in the audience, but they seemed nervous.

[…]

Even in that moment, that guy seemed nervous. There’s this weird silence.

It’s weird to sit with the silence of Siri.

Such a poetic way to put it – it struck me while watching live in the audience, so much so that I wrote it down so I’d remember to post it here.

Watch the full exchange on YouTube.

P.S. Anyone else hear “Hello darkness, my old friend”?